Clienti dirottati alla concorrenza: quando il dipendente deve risarcire il datore di lavoro
June 25 2026

Clients diverted to competitors: when an employee must compensate the employer

Through Ordinance No. 16300 of May 26, 2026, the Supreme Court of Cassation precisely outlines the boundaries of an employee's duty of loyalty. The Court clarifies that diverting clients while the employment relationship is still active constitutes an independent breach of contract, making it unnecessary for employers to prove elements of unfair competition to claim damages.

The case and the regulatory context

The dispute under review stems from the resignation without notice of a physician who served as the technical director of a healthcare facility's dialysis department. The employing company, which subsequently entered bankruptcy proceedings, initiated an action for damages against the professional. The company complained about the depletion of the department, which saw its patient count drop from approximately eighty to about ten immediately following the employee's departure. The Court of Appeal established that the worker, in the days preceding his resignation, contacted patients to direct them toward a competing healthcare facility. The same decision, however, excluded the liability of two other doctors involved, as they were merely independent contractors not subject to an employment relationship of subordination.

The legal issue examined

The core issue concerns the extension of contractual duties typical of subordinate employment compared to independent collaborations. The appellant challenged the order to pay damages, raising two primary objections. On one hand, he highlighted the absence of conduct constituting unfair competition under the Civil Code. On the other hand, he emphasized the healthcare facility's failure to pay his remuneration for over six months. The Supreme Court therefore had to clarify whether an employer's failure to pay wages suspends the effectiveness of the duties of loyalty and whether corporate protection necessarily requires proof of typical anti-competitive conduct.

The court's decision and the ratio decidendi

Through the ruling in the file cass-civ-sez-lavoro-ord-data-ud-09-04-2026-26-05-2-2.pdf (Ordinance No. 16300 of May 26, 2026), the Labour Section of the Supreme Court of Cassation rejected the doctor's appeal, confirming the penalty framework. The ratio decidendi is based on the autonomy of the duty of loyalty provided for by Article 2105 of the Italian Civil Code. The panel specified that this duty requires the employee to refrain from conduct contrary to the employer's interests. This obligation does not coincide with the prohibition of unfair competition regulated by Articles 2598 et seq., which governs objective relations between competing businesses.

Case law interpretation extends the scope of Article 2105 of the Civil Code by integrating it with the general principles of contractual fairness and good faith. Consequently, the predetermination of patient diversion carried out prior to resignation directly harms company assets. The judges established that the conduct is relevant even for its mere potential to cause harm. Furthermore, the Supreme Court rejected the defense argument based on payment delays: the employer's non-performance does not authorize the employee to violate the duty of loyalty as long as the contract remains formally in force.

Related News
Stay updated.
November 22 2026

Fixed-term physicians, Supreme Court of Cassation: seniority under fixed-term contracts counts toward career progression

In Judgment No. 28834 of 10 November 2026, the Labour Section of the Supreme Court of Cassation clarified how service seniority accrued under fixed-term contracts affects the career progression of fixed-term physicians later hired on a permanent basis in the National Health Service. The decision rules out forfeiture under Article 32 of Law No. 183/2010 when a claim seeks only seniority calculation without challenging the fixed term, confirms that managerial appointments are not automatic and remain subject to organizational and evaluation rules, and aligns the start date of seniority-linked allowances with the full five-year period positively assessed, while barring duplicative recovery.

Read
Sunlight streams into an empty classroom with desks
November 13 2026

2.5% TFR deduction for fixed-term workers: the Rome Court of Appeal confirms it is unlawful

The Rome Court of Appeal, by judgment no. 4033 of 13 October 2026, confirmed that the 2.5% TFR deduction applied to fixed-term public sector workers is unlawful. Relying on Court of Cassation orders no. 11663 and no. 19697 of 2023, the ruling clarifies that the pay reduction provided for by Article 1 of the Prime Ministerial Decree of 20 December 1999 applies only to permanent staff, whereas fixed-term relationships are governed by the private-sector rules of Article 2120 of the Civil Code, which impose no deduction on the employee. The decision strengthens the right to recover the amounts withheld and to have the deduction stopped, with direct consequences for substitute teachers, educators and administrative and technical staff.

Read