Medical malpractice: the Court of Rome rules on nosocomial infections
April 7 2026

Medical malpractice: the Court of Rome rules on nosocomial infections

The Court of Rome, in Ruling No. 3386 of March 5, 2026, addressed medical malpractice regarding nosocomial infections contracted during hospitalization. The decision clarifies that while the patient must prove the causal link between the hospital stay and the infection, the burden shifts to the healthcare facility to prove the diligent adoption of all prevention and sanitization protocols. The Court ruled that generic defenses based on the inevitability of infectious risk are insufficient; hospitals must provide rigorous documentary evidence concerning the sterility of environments and medical devices to avoid liability. This approach reinforces the duty of risk management and requires analytical documentation of hospital hygiene procedures to prevent successful compensation claims.

In its recent Ruling No. 3386 of March 5, 2026, the Court of Rome revisited the sensitive issue of medical malpractice regarding nosocomial infections (hospital-acquired infections). This decision provides essential clarifications on the allocation of the burden of proof, defining the specific criteria under which a healthcare facility may be exempted from liability for pathologies contracted during a patient's stay.

Case background and legal framework

The dispute arose from a compensation claim filed by a patient who, following a correctly performed surgical procedure, developed a severe bacterial infection during post-operative recovery. The claimant sued the hospital, alleging a lack of adequate prophylaxis and environmental hygiene measures.

The governing legal framework remains the Gelli-Bianco Law (L. 24/2017), which classifies the liability of healthcare facilities as contractual in nature. This classification has significant procedural implications, particularly concerning the burden of proof in cases of infectious complications, where the line between an "unforeseeable event" and "organizational failure" is often blurred.

The legal issue: the burden of proof

The core of the decision lies in the correct application of the principle of proximity of proof. According to the consolidated orientation confirmed by the Court, a patient fulfills their evidentiary burden by proving:

  • The onset of the infection during the period of hospitalization (or within a timeframe compatible with the known incubation period);
  • The causal link between the hospital stay and the detected pathology.

Once this evidence is provided, the burden shifts to the healthcare facility. To avoid liability, the hospital must demonstrate that it adopted all preventive measures prescribed by clinical guidelines and best practices. This is not a simple task, as it requires proving a "negative fact": namely, that the event was unavoidable despite the exercise of maximum organizational diligence.

The Court’s decision and legal principle

With Ruling No. 3386/2026, the Court of Rome established that a facility cannot merely produce generic certifications regarding premises cleanliness. To rebut the presumption of fault, the hospital must document with precision the actual implementation of sterilization protocols, the proper maintenance of ventilation systems, and the strict adherence to hand-washing procedures by staff.

The Court emphasized that a nosocomial infection is not an "inherent risk" that must always be accepted. Rather, it is an event that the facility must manage through rigorous risk management. The failure to produce sanitization logs or technical data sheets for the medical devices used precludes the facility from invoking an "unknown cause" or the inevitability of the damage.

Operational implications for facilities and patients

This ruling strengthens patient protection while outlining a clear roadmap for healthcare management. Facilities must invest in the total traceability of hygiene processes. The decision highlights three critical points:

  1. Clinical documentation must be comprehensive, covering not only medical treatment but also environmental and logistical aspects.
  2. The absence of documentary evidence regarding compliance with protocols is procedurally equivalent to proof of breach of contract.
  3. Liability for infection can only be excluded if the facility demonstrates that the bacterial strain was resistant to every reasonable and standardized prophylactic measure.
Related News
Stay updated.
November 22 2026

Fixed-term physicians, Supreme Court of Cassation: seniority under fixed-term contracts counts toward career progression

In Judgment No. 28834 of 10 November 2026, the Labour Section of the Supreme Court of Cassation clarified how service seniority accrued under fixed-term contracts affects the career progression of fixed-term physicians later hired on a permanent basis in the National Health Service. The decision rules out forfeiture under Article 32 of Law No. 183/2010 when a claim seeks only seniority calculation without challenging the fixed term, confirms that managerial appointments are not automatic and remain subject to organizational and evaluation rules, and aligns the start date of seniority-linked allowances with the full five-year period positively assessed, while barring duplicative recovery.

Read
Sunlight streams into an empty classroom with desks
November 13 2026

2.5% TFR deduction for fixed-term workers: the Rome Court of Appeal confirms it is unlawful

The Rome Court of Appeal, by judgment no. 4033 of 13 October 2026, confirmed that the 2.5% TFR deduction applied to fixed-term public sector workers is unlawful. Relying on Court of Cassation orders no. 11663 and no. 19697 of 2023, the ruling clarifies that the pay reduction provided for by Article 1 of the Prime Ministerial Decree of 20 December 1999 applies only to permanent staff, whereas fixed-term relationships are governed by the private-sector rules of Article 2120 of the Civil Code, which impose no deduction on the employee. The decision strengthens the right to recover the amounts withheld and to have the deduction stopped, with direct consequences for substitute teachers, educators and administrative and technical staff.

Read